Who's getting the better deal????

[ryanpboerger]

I give...

L. Tomlinson
Torry Holt
L. Coles

I get...

Aaron Brooks
Stephen Davis---supposed to be coming back soon
Javon Walker


My original team is

QB
M. Hasselbeck
B. Leftwich---out 4-6

RB
L. Tomlinson
C. Martin
F. Taylor

WR
Ro. Williams DET
L. Coles WAS
K. Robinson SEA
M. Robinson MINN

TE
B. WIlliams N.O.
L.J. Smith PHI

K
Morten Anderson MINN
Kris Brown HOU

DEF
TENNESSEE
MIAMI

We start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF

[trinity]

As long as you have faith in C-Mart and Taylor to carry you at RB, this looks like a good deal. You get help at QB and WR in exchange.

In my league, here are the season weekly averages for the players involved:

Tomlinson - 10
Holt - 7
Coles - 3

Brooks - 16
Walker - 9
S Davis - 2


After the trade, I'd consider dropping Boo Williams for either another RB (if a decent one is out there) or TE that is actually contributing.

Good luck!

[papasmurf1717]

I would not do it, you are giving up a stud rb who has not yet come to form but should after his bye, to get Brooks who is very inconsistent and prob wont start on your team over Hasselbeck. Plus you will prob never startDavis over your other rb's. Keep LT and attempt to deal Cmart or Taylor for better WR. Either should be close to enought o get Walker straight up.

[RedskinRog]

This would be one of the worst moves you could make, Tomlinson will be back to 100% after the by week. You are drastically decreasing your team, I don't think Brooks in an updrade over Hasselback.

[RocCityBandit]

Don't do it. Davis is rumored to be put on IR.