Colston/Deuce McCallister for Chris Johnson/Wes Welker

[CSweet]

Hey guys.
I get: Colston//Deuce
I give: Chris Johnson/Welker

So I need another sure fire WR and I think Colston gives that to me. My team is listed below in my signature. My team is fairly deep at the RB position w/ Barber, Jacobs, Forte and Chris Johnson. I don't really think I'd start CJ that much over Forte and Wes Welker wouldn't play that much for me either. Pretty much I would be getting a starting WR for 2 bench players.

Do you think I am giving up too much? He also has Tim Hightower who I might counteroffer for with another WR in the deal like Deshaun Jackson. General thoughts would be appreciated.

[daddypoe]

Deuce does nothing for you but with those backs you probably aren't starting Johnson anyways. Welker is more consistent than Randy and Deshaun so I would get rid of one of those two, especially if you are in a PPR league. Coleston hasn't done a whole lot either though since he has been back so I think it is a risk. So in conclusion of my rambling, yeah I think you are giving up too much for someone who is a risk. I'd trade Moss and CoJo for a stud receiver.

[edman688]

I'd hang on to CJo just in case Jacob's injury is worse than expected.

[NYJets30]

I say no. You should trade a RB since you have such good depth, but Colston isnt a big enough improvement over Welker to justify giving up CJo

[Futbol Head]

NO stay away from that one. Duece may be facing suspension.

[CSweet]

Great points by all. I declined the trade proposal. Gracias