Cotchery or Curtis

[kevmvp]

I was having an argument with my friend over who was the better WR. Jerricho Cotchery or Kevin Curtis. I said Cotchery is hands down the better player. Not based just primarily on stats but based on who you would want on your team and things like that.

He said Curtis is better obviously so I decided to ask you guys. Seriously who do you think is better and who would you start your team with Curtis or Cotchery. If i'm wrong I really would like to know. If you vote please give your reason.

I voted for Cotchery obviously. He is bigger and more built to be a number one WR then Curtis is. If your starting your team and you have to pick between these two you would have to pick Cotchery. Curtis is overrated IMO and is really just a solt WR or a solid number 2.

[cubuffsman78]

Neither guy is a No. 1. I'd take Curtis because of his speed and ability to get open. He's a WR much in the sense of Wes Welker. What's wrong with just being a slot receiver? That's where he's best suited, but he proved this season that he can do more when called upon. Cotchery weighs 20 more pounds than Curtis. They're the same height. The biggest difference to me is touchdowns. Curtis has 18. Cotchery has 8. Curtis shows the ability to get more separation from DBs and make big plays to score. Cotchery doesn't have that ability. If either guy is your No. 1 receiver, then you better have a great QB or else your WR corps is crap.