Why Manning isn't the best QB

[PatsFan334]

Bradey is way better at defense. I mean did you see last sundays game? And Manning didnt get anywhere last week. Horrible

[airraid81]

I don't know what you're talking about, but you're obviously a drunk Red Sox fan who jumped on the Pats bandwagon after their first Super Bowl. Manning makes amazing passes and makes everyone on his team better. When you have three 1000+ yd/10+ TD WRs, they aren't all that good. It's the QB. He may not have won an Super Bowls, but take a look at his D, then compare it to the Pats. Manning outplayed Brady. Peice of shit Brady only had 177 yards against the peice of crap Indy D, and Manning had 200+ against one of the NFL's best Ds.

[bob]

49 td passes. Shove that up your ass pats fan.

[PatsFan334]

yeah ok, 49 but where is his superbowl? thats the true time for a QB to shine and he wont make it, at least he didnt this year

[bob]

He'll make it late in his carreer

[airraid81]

"49 but where's his Super Bowl."
That is the most idiotic statement ever. Have you seen Peyton's defense? Brady's team won a Super Bowl, not him. Switch Brady with Manning, and Manning would already have 3 SBs. You seem to think QB is the only posision in football. You know that guy who won a SB for Baltmore. Who was he? You think he's better than Manning because he has a SB? Brady can't make big plays. The only reason he's a good QB is because he doesn't make mistakes. The defense wins the Pats championships.

[Adin]

Dilfer.

There's a bunch more just like him.

Adin

[bravessoccer12]

Originally Posted by PatsFan334 yeah ok, 49 but where is his superbowl? thats the true time for a QB to shine and he wont make it, at least he didnt this year

of course he didn't make it this year. his defence sucks and his line isn't as good as Brady's either. shows a lot about what you know about football

[lions_hb21]

.....the pats top two cornerbacks were out and milloy went to the bills....theres three players that help win every game..if peyton is so good then why didnt he score a td against the pats in the playoffs? peyton choked so bad he threw two ints..thats really bad for someone who just beat the single season td passes record. so dont say bad things about the pats d-fense because what the pats did this year without Law and Poole and Milloy is crazy. that would be like taking marvin harrison, stokley, and the edge away....lets see manning do good without them half a season...theres no i in team so dont give all the credit to peyton...tom brady was a seventh round draft pick. the colts havent beat him yet.

[airraid81]

Peyton had 49 TDs all season. He doesn't even have many weapons. Stockley? Wayne? They aren't anything, but position fillers. They did nothing before Peyton was throwing them the ball. Do you honestly believe that the Colts somehow ended up with 3 WRs that could all have 1000 yds and 10 TDs in the same season? Of course not, it was the QB who gave them those numbers. Who even knows if Harrison is that good? He spent his whole career with Peyton. If you ever watched the Colts play, you would have seen Peyton thread the ball through double coverage with perfect percision. Take away Stockley, and put him on the Patriots. I'd like to see him play there. He'd be behind Branch, Givens, and Patten on the depth chart. You have to have a ton of skill to have 5 straight 4000+ yd/30+ TD seasons. Of course he doesn't beat the Pats. They have Belichick and a great D. Look at the Colts D.