Plax v. Vick

[TNMK]

If you were an NFL GM, which player would you be more willing to take a chance on and why.

I wouldn't think Vick gets a suspension after signing, because he's served time. Plax may be out a few games. Overall, I think Vick is less of a team hazard. I can't imagine him making another big mistake, while Plax very easily could.

[Kevman21]

I think I would go more with Plax. Though I wouldn't sign either. I would only take Plax because I don't think he is any good. He never really was. He was just really athletic. Plax has value on the field while Vick to me has little to none.